Showing posts with label taxation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label taxation. Show all posts

Case Digest - Taxation

Commissioner of Customs vs Milwaukee Industries
GRN- 135253 December 9, 2004
Sandoval-Gutierrez, J.:

Facts:
Milwaukee Industries is engaged in the importation of steel billets and manufactures of them into plates, sheets, pipers, rods etc. for local market of Feb 1, 1994, the steel billets arrived a representative of customs broker for Milwaukee presented to customs inspector a shipside permute and it took 6 days to discharge the cargo. The cargo was transported to the warehouse of respondent but “under guard” until a valid delivery permit was presented. Custom Intelligence and Investigation Division questioned the shipment for being transformed without import entry or payment of duties and taxes. Respondent settled the account while Special Assistant to petitioner was instructed to accept payment and facilitate release of the shipment. North understanding the acceptance and respondent’s payment district collection proceed with the seizure and forfeiture proceedings. Commissioner of Customs affirmed the district collector’s decision. CTA reversed.

Issue:
Whether or not the shipment was released to respondent and that respondent failed to comply with customs requirements to justify seizure and for failure of shipment.

Ruling:
CTA found and held that at the time of the transfer to Milwaukee’s factory, the same was not released but merely transformed or discharged under continuous customs guarding. Since the shipment was merely transfer under the custody of the BOC for all legal intents and purposes.
Section 1202 of TCC provides “Importation is deemed terminated upon payment of the duties, taxes and other charges due upon the articles…and the legal permit for withdrawal shall have been granted.
The seizure proceeding must fail.





R.V Marzan Freight vs. CA/ Shiela’s Manufacturing
GRN 128064

Facts:
Philfire issued insurance policy to R.V Marzan, owner of a customs bonded warehouse. Shiela’s manufacturing engaged in the garment business, the consignee of raw materials from Taiwan. The BOC treated the materials as subject to ordinary import taxes and were not immediate released to respondent. The consignee failed to file the requisite import entry and to claim the cargo.BOC authorized petitioners for stripping and safekeeping after 5 months, notice of abandonment giving respondents 15 days from notice to file entry the file cargoes without prejudice to right of the consignee to redeem articles cargoes would redeemed abandoned and be sold at public auction. After a month the declaration of abandonment has become final and executory but before inventory and sale public auction of goods the warehouse was burned. Philfire paid 12,000.00 for the warehouse. After the Lapse of more than 2 years from the arrival of the cargo, the private respondent filed a complaint for damaged before RTC. Petitioner arrived that there is no private of Contract between them since the cargo was received from BOC and that respondent failed to claim the cargo, pay taxes thus not entitled to insurance proceeds.

Issue:
Whether or not the trial court had jurisdiction to review and declare ineffective the declaration of the BOC in abandonment proceedings and that the government ipso facto became the owner thereof.

Ruling:
The declaration that the cargo was abandoned for the failure to file the import entry was ineffective because notice of proceedings of abandonment was not given to the consignee. Evidently, the resolution of this issue is within the exclusive competence of the District Collector of Customs, the Commissioner of Customs and within the appellate jurisdiction of CTA.
The rule has RTC has no review powers over such proceedings is anchored upon the policy of placing un necessary hindrance on the government drive not only to prevent smuggling and other frauds upon customs, but more importantly, to render effective and efficient the collection of import and export duties due the State, which enables the government to carry out the functions it has been instituted to the perform. The trial court should have dismissed the complaint without prejudice to the right of the private respondent to ventilate the issue before the Commissioner of the Customs and/or CTA.



Terminal Facilities TEFASCO/ Vs. PPA
GRN 135826 February 27, 2002
De Leon, Jr. &:

Facts:
Tefasco proposed to construct as specialized terminal complex with part facilities and a provision for sport services in Davao City. On May 7, 1976, PPA accepted the projects TOCs and was authorized to start work. Tefasco contracted dollar lessons concern from private commercial institution abroad to construct its specialized facilities and long after the ground breaking, PPA passed a resolution which imposed a construction; PPA issued another permit the provision of which states that 10% of arrastre and stevedoring gross income and 100% wharf age and berthing charges be given as government share it had paid and for damage as a result of alleged illegal exaction from its clients of 100% berthing and wharf age fees. RTC ruled for Tefasco.

Issue:
Whether or not the collection of 100% wharf age fees and berthing charge are valid.

Ruling:
The authorization for a Tefasco to construct a port was truly a binding construct between the parties. It was a 2-way advantage for both parties which were the consideration for the contract. The right- privilege dechotomy came to an end when courts realized that individuals should not be subjected to the unfettered whims of government officials to withhold privileges previously given them.
In as much as the part is privately owned and maintained, we rule that applicable rate for imported or exported articles loaded or unloaded thereat is not more than 100% but only 50%.
As regards berthing charges, the Court’s opinion is that only vessels berthing at the national ports arte liable for berthing fees. The Berthing fees imposed upon vessels berthing are national ports are applied by the national government for the maintenance ports. The national ports does not maintain municipal ports which are solely maintain by private entities or municipalities. Thus, PPA erred in collecting berthing fees.




Nestle Philippines, Inc. vs. CA
GRN 134114 July 6, 2001
De Leon, Jr. &:

Facts:
CTA Dismissed petitioners motion to grant refund on allegedly overpaid impost duties, on its various importations of milk and milk products in the amount of 5M. Petitioners were assessed customs duties and advance sales taxes by Collector of Customs for each separate importations on the basis of the published Home Consumption Value. Petitioners paid the same but under protests. On October 1986, petitioner finally failed a claim for refund of before BIR and the following day, filed the petition for review with CTA which ordered BIR to refund P 4,489 representing the overpaid advance and Sales Taxes. The refund for alleged overpaid customs duties amounting to P 5.008M were left with the collector of customs undecided after almost 6 years. On Aug 22, 1990, petition filed a petition for review with CTA dismissed for what of jurisdiction. Case was filed with CA on certiorari (Rule 45) but dismissed for CTA jurisdiction is not concurrent with the appellate jurisdiction of Commissioner since there was no decision yet from Collector from Customs.

Issue:
Whether or not petitioner is entitled for alleged overpayment of customs duties on importations thus be remanded to CTA for further review.

Ruling:
We find that the recommended remand of the case to CTA is warranted. For the proper verification and determination of the factual basis and merits of this petition and in order that the ends of substantial justice and fair play my be sub served. Tariff and Customs Code provides that in all claims for refund of customs duties are paid and upon receipts of such claims is mandated to verify the same by the record of his office. In such claim is found correct and in accordance with law, the collector shall certify the same to the commissioner with his recommendation together with all the necessary papers and documents.
Solutio indebt it’s misplaced because there is no factual showing that the collection was more than what is required of the petitioner when it made the importations. There is no factual finding yet that petitioner is indeed entitled to its claim of overpayment and if how much is he entitled.



CIR vs. Wyeth Suaco Lab
GRN-76281 September 30, 1991

Facts:
An investigation and examination of the books of accounts of Wyeth disclosed that Wyeth was paying royalties to Wyeth International and have also declared cash dividends on September 27, 1973 and these were paid on October 3, 1973. It allegedly failed to remit withholding tax at source and accrued royalties resulting to tax deficiency. Assessment notice were received on December1974 whereas letters/reply were sent on Feb 1975 protesting assessment and requesting their cancellation or withdrawal. On December 10, 1979 petitioner rendered a decision reducing the assessment of withholding tax at source. There after, petitioner issued a warrant of distrait of personal; property and warrant of levy real property. CTA decided in favor of respondent ratiocinating that an assessment of any internal revenue tax within the 5 years period of limitation may be collected by distrait of personal property and warrant of levy of real property. CTA decided in favor of respondent ratiocinating that an assessment of any internal revenue tax within the 5 years period of limitation may be collected by distained or levy by a proceeding in count but only if begun within 5 years after the assessment of the tax.

Issue:
Whether or not the right to collect deficiency tax at source and sales tax liabilities from private respondent is barred by prescription.

Ruling:
Settled is a rule that the prescription period provided by law to make collection by distrait or levy by proceeding in court is interrupted once a tax payers requests of reinvestigation or reconsideration of assessment when Wyeth, through SGV and Co protests the assessment and sought its reconsideration on Feb 1975, the prescription period was interrupted. This period started to run again when the BIR served the final assessment of Wyeth on Jan 2, 1980. Since the warrant of distrait and levy were served on Wyeth on March 12, 1980 then only about for months of the five year prescriptive period was used.

Case Digest - Local Taxation

Mactan Cebu (MCIAA) vs. Marcos

GR 120082 September 11, 1996 261 SCRA 667

Davide Jr., .: (CJ)

FACTS:

Mactan Cebu International Airport Authority (MCIAA) was created to “principally undertake to economical, efficient and effective control, management and supervision of the Mactan International Airport… and such other airports as may be established in the province of Cebu…” Section 14 of its charter excempts the Authority from payment of realty taxes but in 1994, the City Treasurer demanded payment for realty taxes on several parcels of land belonging to the other. MCIAA filed a petition in RTC contending that, by nature of its powers and functions, it has the same footing of an agency or instrumentality of the national government. The RTC dismissed the petition based on Section 193 & 234 of the local Government Code or R.A. 7160. Thus this petition.

ISSUE:

Whether or not the MCIAA is excempted from realty taxes?

RULING:

With the repealing clause of RA 7160 the tax exemption provided. “All general and special in the charter of the MCIAA has been expressly repeated. It state laws, acts, City Charters, decrees, executive orders, proclamations and administrative regulations, or part of parts thereof which are inconsistent with any of the provisions of the Code are hereby repeated or modified accordingly.” Therefore the SC affirmed the decision and order of the RTC and herein petitioner has to pay the assessed realty tax of its properties effective January 1, 1992 up to the present.


Jesus Estanislao vs. Amado Costales

GRN 96516 May 8, 1991 / 196 SCRA 853

Gancayco, J.:

FACTS:

The Sanggunian Panglungsod passed ordinance No 44 of Zamboanga City. The same was sent to the Minister of Finance where it was found out to contravenes Section 19 of the local Tax Code. The authority of the city is limited to the imposition of a percentage tax on the gross sales or receipts of said production. The tax being imposed in the ordinance is based on the output or production and not on the gross sales or receipts as authorized under the local tax code. The city Mayor of Zamboanga questioned such decision of the Finance Minister and the lower court ruled in favor of the former by reason of prescription. The ordinance imposed P0.01 per liter of softdrinks produced, manufactured and or bottled within the territorial jurisdiction of the City of Zamboanga.

ISSUE:

Whether or not Ordinance No. 44 contravenes the Local Tax Code of 1974.

RULING:

The court ruled that the tax ordinances issued by the local autonomy is governed by the Local Tax Code of 1974 as it was stated in Section 64 (a) thereof all existing tax ordinances of provinces, cities, municipalities and barrios shall be deemed ipso facto nullified on June 30, 1974. The court also clarified that the 120 days that lapsed before the Minister of Finance acted on the ordinance did not render the action inoperative due to prescription. Even if the Secretary of Finance failed to review or act on the ordinance within 120 days, it does not follow as a legal consequence thereof that an otherwise invalid ordinance is thereby validated. It does not also mean that the Secretary can no longer act by suspending and/or revoking an invalid ordinance even after the lapse of 120 day period.


Phil Petroleum Corporation vs. Mun of Pililia, Rizal

GR 90776 June 3, 1991 / 198 SCRA 82

Paras, J.:

Facts:

Petitioner, Philippine Petroleum Corporation (PPC) owns and maintains an oil refinery conducting business within the municipality of Pililia, Rizal. P.D. 231 or the local tax code of 1973 provide for the Municipality of impose taxes on business any article of commerce. Thereafter, Provincial Circular 26-73 was issued directing all provincial, City and municipal treasurers to refrain from collecting any local imposed in petroleum products. In 1974, P.D. 426 amended certain provisions of P.D. 231. The municipality of Pililia, through Municipal Tax ordinance 1, S-1974, imposed tax on business. In the RTC, respondent received a favorable decision, directing herein petitioner to pay the tax and fees impose unto it. Petitioner contended that Provincial Arcular 26-73 suspended the effectively of local tax ordinances of the local tax code.

ISSUE:

Whether or not Provincial Circular No. 26-73 supersedes the provisions of P.D. 231 as amended by P.D. 426?

RULING:

The court ruled in the negative, stating that “in case of discrepancy between the basic law and on implementing rule or regulation, the former prevails.” P.D. 426, amending the local tax code repealed P.C. No. 26-73 and 26-A73 where section 19 of which stated “the municipality may impose taxes on business… manufacturers importers or producers of any article of commerce of whatever kind or nature…”

Thus, the order of the lower court was affirmed by SC with certain modification. In the case at bar, the provisions of the local tax code of 1974 supersedes P.C. 26-73, likewise upholding the constitutional right granted to local autonomy to imposed taxes.


Jardine Davies Insurance vs. Aliposo

GRN 118900 February 27, 2003

Callejo, Sr. J.:

FACTS:

Makati enacted Municipal Ordinance 92-072 which provides for the schedule of real estate, business and franchise taxes in Makati. PRCI appealed the ordinance with the DOJ assailing invalidity due to lack of public hearing, in violation of RA 7160. DOJ declared it null and void while pending appeal to SC, Makati continued to implement the ordinance. Petitioner Jardine paid its deficiency taxes without any protest. In 1995, Jardine requested for tax credit or refund which Makati denied reasoning that until nullified by final judgment of competent court, the ordinance remained in full force & effect. RTC dismissed petitioner’s case ruling that plaintiff’s cause of action has prescribed. Petition for review under Rule 45 was filed.

ISSUE:

Whether or not a protest must first be filed before an action for refund/credit in instituted.

RULING:

As a general precept, a taxpayer may file a complaint assailing the validity of the ordinance and praying for a refund of its overpayments without first filing a protest to the payment of taxes due the ordinance. However, petitioner was prescribed from filing its complaint with RTC for the reason that petitioner failed to appeal to Sec. of the Justice within 30 days from affectivity of ordinance as provided by Sec 187, RA 7160.

Failure of taxpayer to interpose the requisite appeal to DOJ is fatal to its complaint for a refund. Any delay in implementing tax measures would be to the detriment of the public. It is for this reason that protests over tax ordinances are required to be done within certain time frames. Moreover, petitioner even paid without any protest the amounts of taxes assessed by respondents as provided for in the ordinance. The complaint was a mere afterthought.


Lim vs CA/PP

GRN L- 48134-37 October 18, 1990

Fernan, J.:

Facts:

Petitioner Spouses (Lim) were engaged in a Lendership business. A Raid was made on their promises and seized were business and accounting records which served as bases for an investigation by BIR. Findings reveal that income tax filed for 1958/1959 were false or fraudulent. BIR referred the case to Manila for investigation and prosecution. RTC found spouses guilty but Emilio Lim died and CA resolved that counsel petitioners should inform the court as to who are the heirs of Emilio.


Issue:

Whether or not the civil obligation arising from the crime charged was extinguished by his death.

Ruling:

Indubitably, petitioners had filed false and fraudulent income tax returns for the years 1958 and 1959 by non-disclosure of sales in the aggregate amount of P 2,197,742.92 thereby depriving the government in the amount of P 1,237,190.55 representing deficiency income taxes inclusive of interest, surcharges and compromise penalty for the late payment. Considering it occurred in the 50’s the defraudation was on a massive scale. It is clear that criminal conviction for a violation of any penal provision in the tax code does not mount at the same time to a decision for a payment of the unpaid taxes in as much as there is no specific provision in the tax code prior to its amendment. The trial court did not order the payment of the unpaid taxes as a part of the sentence. The supervening death of Emilio has extinguished his liability with regard to the pecuniary penalty of fine imposed on the deceased.

The crime of filling false return can be considered discovered only after the manner of commission and the nature and extent of the fraud have been definitely ascertained. It was only Oct. 10, 1967 when the BIR rendered its decision holding that there was no ground for the reversal of the assessment and therefore required the petitioners to pay deficiency taxes that the tax infractions were discovered.

Yamane vs BA Lepanito Condominium Corp.

GRN: 154993, October 25,2005

Tinga, J.:

Facts;

The Condominium is authorized to collect regular assessments from its members for operating expenses, capital, and expenditures on the common areas and other special assessment as provided for in its CBL on Dec. 15, 1998, the corporation sought for the legal basis of said assessment Yamane responded that the corporation is in engaged in the business and that the collection of dues has for its ends a better marketable prices for occupants who would in the future sell their units. RTC concluded that the activities of the corporation fall squarely under the definition of business under Sec 13 of LGC, and thus subject to local business taxation.

Issue:

Whether or not a Local government unit can impel a condominium corporation to pay business taxes.

Ruling:

The power of Local Government units to impose taxes within its territorial jurisdiction derives from the constitution. Section 143 of LGC specifically enumerates several types of business on which municipalities and cities may impose taxes but none refers to case at bar. In fact, nowhere in is there any citation by city treasurer as to the legal authority upon which the collection of business tax from corporation was based.

To subject a corporation to a business taxes, its activities must fall within the definition of business provided in local government Code. We can Elicit from condominium act that condominium corporation is precluded by statistic from engaging in corporate activities other than the holding of common areas, the administration of the condominium project and other acts necessary, incidental or convenient to the accomplishment of such purposes. There is no contemplation of business and the assessment appears to be solely based on corporation’s collection of assessment from unit owners which was used to defray expense of the condominium.

Case Digest - Taxation

Obillos et al vs. CIR/CA
GRN – L68118 October 29, 1985
Aquino, J.:

FACTS:
Petitioners sold the lots they inherited from their father and derived a total profit of P33,584 for each of them. They treated the profit as capital gain and paid an income tax thereof. The CIR required petitioners to pay corporate income tax on their shares, .20% tax fraud surcharge and 42% accumulated interest. Deficiency tax was assessed on the theory that they had formed an unregistered partnership or joint venture.

ISSUE:
Whether or not partnership was formed by the siblings thus be assessed of the corporate tax.

RULING:
Petitioners were co-owners and to consider them partners would obliterate the distinction between co-ownership and partnership. The petitioners were not engaged in any joint venture by reason of that isolated transaction.

Art 1769… the sharing of gross returns does not of itself establish a partnership, whether or not the persons sharing them have a joint or common right or interest in any property from which the returns are derived. There must be an unmistakable intention to form partnership or joint venture.


Mobil Philippines vs. City Treasure of Makati
GRN 154092 July 14, 2005
Quisumbing, J.:

FACTS:
Petitioner’s office was located in Makati City when it filed an application with the City Treasurer for retirement of business within Makati as it moved its business to Pasig City, on September 1998. After evaluation, petitioner was assessed business tax in the amount of P1,898,106.96. Petitioner paid the tax under protest and in 1999, claimed a refund therefrom. RTC denied the petition for refund ratiocinating that… the payments made by mobil in 1998 are payments for business tax for 1997 which occurred in January of 1998.

ISSUE:
Whether or not the business taxes paid in 1998, business taxes for 1997.

RULING:
Business taxes imposed in the exercise of police power for regulatory purposes are paid for the privilege of carrying on a business in the year the tax was paid. It is paid at the beginning of the year as a fee to allow the business to operate for the rest of the year. The business taxes paid n the year 1998 is for the privilege of engaging in business for the same year. Thus we find that the respondent erroneously treated the assessment and collection of business tax as if it were income tax, by rendering an additional assessment of P1,331,638.84 for the revenue generated for the year 1998.


PFDA vs. CA/Navotas

GRN 150301 October 2, 2007

Azcuña, J.:

FACTS:

Respondent Navotas assessed real estate taxes due from petitioner PFDA for the period 1981-1990 on properties under its jurisdiction, management and operation located inside the Navotas Fishing Port Complex. The assessed taxes remained unpaid, the complex was scheduled for a public auction. Despite DOF’s order to make an ocular inspection of said complex, respondent municipality proceeded with the sale. RTC issued writ of preliminary injunction enjoining Navotas from proceeding with the auction. RTC subsequently dismissed the case, ratiocinating that: “assailing the validity of the tax assessments of the NFPC propertiers is not the proper recourse of the plaintiff but to pay first the assessments under protest and then raise the same on appeal to the LBAA, then to CBAA then ultimately to CTA. CA affirmed the ruling.”

ISSUE:

Whether or not petitioner is liable to pay the assessed tax.

RULING:

“Common limitations to the taxing power of LGU’s are those… taxes, fees, charges of any kind on the national government, its agencies and instrumentalities, and local government units.” This does not apply when the beneficial use of the government property has been granted to a taxable person. Thus, as a rule, PFDA, being an instrumentality of the national government, is exempt from real property tax but the exemption does not extend to the portions of the NFPC that were leased to taxable or private persons and entities for their beneficial use. NFPC cannot be sold at public auction in satisfaction of the tax delinquency assessments made by the municipality on the entire complex. The land on which the NFPC property sits is a reclaimed land, which belongs to the state.

FELS ENERGY vs. BATANGAS

GRN 168557 February 16, 2007

Callejo, J.:

FACTS:

Power energy leased its power barge to NPC for a period of 5 years. In the agreement, NPC was made to shoulder any tax expenses related to the power barge then Polar assigned its rights to FELS. Batangas assessed the property and FELS referred the matter to NPC pursuant to the Agreement. NPC sought reconsideration to Provincial Assessor but was denied. LBAA affirmed provincial assessor while CBAA found the power barges exempt from real property tax, consequently reversed its own ruling. FELS & NPC separately filed a petition for review before CA.

ISSUE:

Whether or not local assessor has the jurisdiction to entertain any request for a review or readjustment.

RULING:

The appropriate forum where the aggrieved party may bring his appeal is the LBAA as provided by law. It follows that the 60-day period for making the appeal to LBAA runs without interruption.

If the taxpayer fails to appeal in due course, the right of the local government to collect the taxes due with respect to the taxpayer’s property becomes absolute upon the expiration of the period to appeal. Also, failure of taxpayer to question the assessment in the LBAA renders the assessment of the local assessor final, executory and demandable, thus precluding the taxpayer from questioning the correctness of the assessment, or from invoking any defense that would re open the question of its liability on the merits.

Dgigitel vs. Pangasinan

GRN 152 534 February 23, 2007

Chico-Nazario, J:

FACTS:

Pangasinan filed a petition for Mandamus, Collection of Sum of Money and Damages against Digitel on March 1, 2000. LGC withdrew any exemption from payment of a tax on businesses enjoying a franchise and authorized LGU’s to impose a franchise tax, on business enjoying a franchise within its territorial jurisdiction. (Sec 137, RA 7160) under Provincial Ordinance, Digitel was granted a provincial franchise but was required to pay franchise & real property taxes. Pangasinan likewise enacted “The Real Property Tax Ordinance of 1992” and technically expanded the application of franchise to include machineries and other improvements, thereinafter exempted to Digitel. Since 92, 93 & 94, Digitel allegedly had a franchise tax deficiency which hasn’t been paid since the start of its operation. In 1995, congress passed RA 7925, “The public Telecoms Policy Act Section 23 provided: for the application to any previously granted telecoms franchises of any advantage granted under existing franchise.”

ISSUE:

Whether or not Digitel is entitled to the exemption from the payment of provincial franchise tax in view of RA 7925.

RULING:

Prior to the enactment and effectivity of its legislative franchise, with only a provincial franchise to speak of, Digitel did not enjoy any exemption from payment of franchise and real property taxes. The word exemption as used in RA 7925 pertains to an exemption from regulatory or reporting requirements of the DOTC or the NTC and not to the grantee’s tax liability. In many resolved cases, the Court ruled that

“when exemption is claimed, it must be shown indubitably to exist… a well-founded doubt is fatal to the claim. It is only when the terms of the concession are too explicit to admit fairly of any other, construction that the preposition can be supported.”

On whether Congerss may lift the taxing power of LGU, Court said: “the grant of taxing powers to LGU’s under LGC does not affect the power of Congress to grant exemptions to certain persons, pursuant to a declared national policy. The legal effect of that in interpreting statutory provisions on municipal corporations. Congress exempted real property tax on those properties actually, exclusively and direcdtly used by DIGITEL in the pursuit of its franchise.”


Reyes vs. CA

GRN 118233 December 10, 1999

Quisumbing; J.: en banc

FACTS:

San Juan, MM implemented several tax ordinances and on May 1993, petitioners filed an appeal to DOJ assailing the constitutionality of these ordinances because they were promulgated without a public hearing. Secretary dismissed the case for having been filed out of time, under Sec. 187, RA 7160. CA affirmed.

ISSUE:

Whether or not the constitutional validity of Sec 187 of LGC to could be raised for the first time on appeal.

RULING:

Petitioners claim that the alleged failure of San Juan to conduct public hearing, ordinances were inoperative and that no prescriptive 30-day period to question the validity of the ordinance could toll to bar appeal to DOJ. The provisions of Sec 187, RA 7160 are set to prevent delays as well as enhance the orderly and speedy discharge of judicial functions. In the instant case, it is our view that failure of petitioners to appeal to the Secretary of Justice within 30 days as required by RA 7160 is fatal to their case. On the issue of its validity, the constitutionality of an act of Congress will not be passed upon by the Court unless at the first opportunity, that question is properly raised and presented in an appropriate case, and is necessary to determination of the case, particularly where the issue of constitutionality is very lis mota presented.

Case Digest - Taxation Law

International Exchange Bank vs. CIR
GRN 171266/520 SCRA 688 April 4, 2007
Carpio-Morales; J.;
FACTS:
An examination of book of accounts of the bank resulted to an assessment of tax liabilities of the latter amounting to P465,158,118.31 for 1996 and P17,033,311,974.23 for 1997. Details of PAN included: Savings-Deposit-ESO amounting to P9,845,800.27 should be treated as time deposits considering that its features are very much the same as time deposits... subject to DST. CTA ordered payment of DST on SA-FSD.

ISSUE:
Whether or not SA-FSD evidenced by a passbook is subject to DST?

RULING:
As correctly found by CTA, En Bans, a passbook representing an interest earning deposit account issued by a bank qualifies as a certificate of deposit earning interest.
In this case, a depositor of savings deposit FSD is required to keep the money with the bank for at least 30 days in order to yield a higher interest pertaining only to a regular savings deposit… the only difference lies on the evidence of deposits a SA-FSD is evidence by a passbook, while a time deposit is evidence by a certificate of time deposit.

===========================
Marcos II vs. CA/CIR
GRN 120880 June 5, 1997
Torres, J.:

FACTS:
After the death of former President Marcos, Special audit team disclosed that Marcoses failed to file a written notice of the death of the decedent, an estate tax returns as well as several income tax returns covering the years 1982 to 1986. BIR issued deficiency estate tax assessment among others and were personally and constructively served to the last known address of Marcoses. No administrative protest were served by Imelda or the heir of the late President, thus notices of levy on real property were issued. Having no response, properties were awarded in favor of the government. Marcos II questioned the levy assailing that said properties were under probate hearing thus, should not be summarily levied by BIR.

ISSUE:
Whether or not the BIR has authority to collect by the summary remedy of levying upon, and sale of real properties of the decedent, estate tax deficiencies, without the cognition and authority of the court sitting in probate over the supposed will of the deceased.

RULING:
The approval of the curt, sitting in probate, or as a settlement tribunal over the deceased is not a mandatory requirement in the collection of estate taxes… there is nothing in the tax code, and in the pertinent remedial laws that implies the necessity of the probate or estate settlement court’s approval of the state’s claim for the estate taxes, before the same can be enforced and collected. If there is any issue as to the validity of the BIR’s decision to assess the estate taxes, this should have been pursued through the proper administrative and judicial avenues provided for by law.

Even an assessment based on the estimate is prima facie valid and lawful where it does not appear to have been arrived at arbitrarily or capriciously. The burden of proof is upon the complaining party to show clearly that the assessment is erroneous.

NB: The nature of the process of estate tax collection
…the inheritance tax does not directly involve the administration of the decedent’s estate although it may be viewed as an incident to the complete settlement of an estate, and under some statutes, it is made the duty of the probate court to make the amount of the inheritance tax a part of the final decree of distribution of the estate. It is not against the property of decedent, nor it is a claim against the estate as much, but it is against the interest or property right which the heir… has in the property formerly held by decedent… it is a proceeding in rem.

=======================
CIR vs. Solid Bank
GRN 148191 November 25, 2003
Panganiban, J.;

FACTS:
Solid Bank declared gross receipts included the amount from passive income which was already subjected to 20% final withholding tax (FWT). CTA affirmed that the 20% FWT should not form part of its taxable gross receipts for purpose of computing the gross receipts tax on such basis, Bank filed a request for refund. CTA ordered the refund while CA held that indeed, the 20% FWT on a bank’s interest income does not form part of the taxable gross receipts in computing the 5% GRT because the FWT was not actually received by the bank, but was directly remitted to the government.

ISSUE:
Whether or not the 20% FWT on a bank’s interest income forms part of the taxable gross receipts in computing the 5% gross receipts tax.

RULING:
In China Banking vs. CA, this Court ruled that the amount interest income withheld in payment of 20% FWT forms part of the gross receipts in computing for the GRT on banks.
A percentage tax is a national tax measured by a certain percentage of the gross selling price or gross value in money of goods sold, bartered or imported; or of the gross receipts or earnings derived by any person engaged in the sale of services. It is not subject to withholding.
An income tax is national tax imposed on the net or the gross income realized in a taxable year.

It is subject to withholding.
In a withholding tax system, the payee is the taxpayer, the person on whom tax is reposed, the payer, a separate entity, acts as no more than an agent of the government for the collection of taxes… Possession is acquired by the payer as the withholding agent of the government because the taxpayer ratifies the very act of possession for the government. There is constructive receipt, of such income and is included as part of the tax base.


=========================
China Bank vs CA
GRN 125508 July 19, 2000
Vitug, J.:

FACTS:
Petitioner CBC made a 53% equity investment in the First CBC, a Hongkong subsidiary engaged in financing and investment with “deposit-taking” function. First, CBC became insolvent and with approval from Bangko Sentral, petitioner wrote-off as being worthless its investment in First CBC, and its 1987 Income Tax Return, it treated as bad credit or an ordinary loss deductible from its gross income. CIR disallowed the deduction on the ground that although 1st CBC ceased to be a deposit-taking company, still it can exercise its financing and investment activities. Assuming that it become “worthless”, it should have been a capital loss, and not as a bad debt expense, there being no indebtedness to speak of between petitioner and its subsidiary.

ISSUE:
Whether or not “securities becoming worthless” be allowed as deduction from gross income of CBC.

RULING:
An equity investment is a capital, not ordinary asset of the investor, the sale or exchange in which results in either a capital gain or capital loss. The gain or loss is ordinary when the property sold or exchanged is not a capital asset. Sec 29 of NIRC on securities becoming worthless during the tax year are capital assets, the loss resulted therefrom shall be considered as a loss from the sale or exchange, on the last day of such taxable year, of capital assets.

A capital gain or a capital loss normally requires the concurrence of two conditions for it to result: 1) there is a sale or exchange; 2) the thing sold or exchanged is a capital asset. Capital losses are allowed to be deducted only to the extent of capital gains, e.i. gains derived from the sale or exchange of capital assets, and not from any other income of the taxpayer… any capital loss can be deducted only from capital gains.

======================
AFISCO Insurance et al vs. CA/CTA/CIR
GRN 112675 January 25, 1999
Panganiban, J.:

FACTS:
The 41 non-life insurance corporation entered into a Qouta Share Reinsurance Treaty with Munich, non-resident corporation. The reinsurance treaty required petitioners to form a pool. CA ruled that the pool of machinery was a partnership taxable as a corporation, and that the latter’s collection of premiums on behalf of its members was taxable income.

ISSUE:
Whether or not the “insurance” pool be taxable as an incorporation and its remittances be taxable as dividends.

RULING:
The Philippine legislative included in the concept of corporation those entities that resembled them such as unregistered partnerships and associations. Section 24 covered unregistered partnerships and even associations and joint accounts, which had no legal personalities apart from their individual members.
The term “partnership” includes a syndicate group, pool, joint venture or other unincorporated organization, through or by means of which any business financial operation or venture is carried on.
The pool is taxable entity distinct from the individual corporate entities of the insurance companies. The tax on income is different from the tax on dividends received by said companies, thus no double taxation.

Case Digest - Local Government Tax

Basco et al vs. PAGCOR
G.R. No. 91649 May 14, 1991
FACTS:
PD 1869 is the charter which created the Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation. PAGCOR was created to enable the government to regulate and centralize all games of chance authorized by existing franchise or permitted by law. Section 13 par 2 of the decree exempts PAGCOR, franchise holder from paying any “tax of any kind or form, income or otherwise… whether national or local”. According to the petitioners, this waived the Manila City government’s right to impose taxes and license fees which is recognized by law.
ISSUE:
Whether or not the exemption clause of PD 1869 is violative of the principle of local autonomy?
RULING:
The city of Manila, being a municipal corporation has no inherent right to impose taxes. Its power to tax must always yield to a legislative act which is superior having been passed upon by the state which has the inherent power of the state to tax.
The court added that since one of the roles of PAGCOR is to regulate gambling casinos, this “places it in the category of an agency or instrumentality of the government…” PAGCOR should be and actually is exempted from local taxes, otherwise, its operation might be burdened, impeded, or subjected to control by a mere local government.
The matter of regulating, taxing or otherwise dealing with gambling is a state concern and hence, it is the sole prerogative of the state to retain it or delegate it to local government.

Bar Exam 2010 - Taxation Questions

PART I I
True or False.
A. In civil cases involving the collection of internal revenue taxes, prescription is construed strictly against the government and liberally in favor of the taxpayer. (1%)
B. In criminal cases involving tax offenses punishable under the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC), prescription is construed strictly against the government. (1%)
C. In criminal cases where the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) has exclusive original jurisdiction, the right to file a separate civil action for the recovery of taxes may be reserved. (1%)
D. Proceedings before the CTA in the exercise of its exclusive original jurisdiction are in the nature of trial de novo. (1%)
E. Judgments, resolutions or orders of the Regional Trial Court in the exercise of its original jurisdiction involving criminal offenses arising from violations of the NIRC are appealable to the CTA, which shall hear the cases en banc. (1%)
II A. What is the “all events test”? Explain briefly. (2%)
B. What is the “immediacy test”? Explain briefly. (2%) C. What is the “rational basis” test? Explain briefly. (2%)
D. What is the effect of the execution by a taxpayer of a “waiver of the statute of limitations” on his defense of prescription? (2%)
Taxation Page 3 of 11
E. What is the basis for the computation of business tax on contractors under the Local Government Code? (2%)
F. How are retiring businesses taxed under the Local Government Code? (2%)
III
Mirador, Inc., a domestic corporation, filed its Annual Income Tax Return for its taxable year 2008 on April 15, 2009. In the Return, it reflected an income tax overpayment of P1,000,000.00 and indicated its choice to carry-over the overpayment as an automatic tax credit against its income tax liabilities in subsequent years.
On April 15, 2010, it filed its Annual Income Tax Return for its taxable year 2009 reflecting a taxable loss and an income tax overpayment for the current year 2009 in the amount of P500,000.00 and its income tax overpayment for the prior year 2008 of P1,000,000.00.
In its 2009 Return, the corporation indicated its option to claim for refund the total income tax overpayment of P1,500,000.00
Choose which of the following statements is correct.
A. Mirador, Inc. may claim as refund the total income tax overpayment of P1,500,000.00 reflected in its income tax return for its taxable year 2009;
B. It may claim as refund the amount of P500,000.00 representing its income tax overpayment for its taxable year 2009; or
C. No amount may be claimed as refund. Explain the basis of your answer. (5%)
Taxation Page 4 of 11
IV
On March 10, 2010, Continental, Inc. received a preliminary assessment notice (PAN) dated March 1, 2010 issued by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR) for deficiency income tax for its taxable year 2008. It failed to protest the PAN. The CIR thereupon issued a final assessment notice (FAN) with letter of demand on April 30, 2010. The FAN was received by the corporation on May 10, 2010, following which or on May 25, 2010, it filed its protest against it.
The CIR denied the protest on the ground that the assessment had already become final and executory, the corporation having failed to protest the PAN.
Is the CIR correct? Explain. (5%)
V
Does the Court of Appeals have the power to review compromise agreements forged by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and a taxpayer? Explain. (5%)
VI
Based on the Affidavit of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR), an Information for failure to file income tax return under Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) was filed by the Department of Justice (DOJ) with the Manila Regional Trial Court (RTC) against XX, a Manila resident.
XX moved to quash the Information on the ground that the RTC has no jurisdiction in view of the absence of a formal deficiency tax assessment issued by the CIR.
Is a prior assessment necessary before an Information for violation of Section 255 of the NIRC could be filed in court? Explain. (4%)
Taxation Page 5 of 11
VII
What are the conditions that must be complied with before the Court of Tax Appeals may suspend the collection of national internal revenue taxes? (3%)
VIII
What is the rule on appeal from decisions of the Collector of Customs in protest and seizure cases? When is the decision of the Collector of Customs appealable to the Court of Tax Appeals? Explain. (5%)
IX
On May 15, 2009, La Manga Trading Corporation received a deficiency business tax assessment of P1,500,000.00 from the Pasay City Treasurer. On June 30, 2009, the corporation contested the assessment by filing a written protest with the City Treasurer.
On October 10, 2009, the corporation received a collection letter from the City Treasurer, drawing it to file on October 25, 2009 an appeal against the assessment before the Pasay Regional Trial Court (RTC).
A. Was the protest of the corporation filed on time? Explain. (3%)
B. Was the appeal with the Pasay RTC filed on time? Explain. (3%)
- END OF PART I-
Taxation Page 6 of 11
PART II X
True or False. (1% each) A. Gains realized by the investor upon redemption of shares of
stock in a mutual fund company are exempt from income tax.
B. A corporation can claim the optional standard deduction equivalent to 40% of its gross sales or receipts, as the case may be.
C. Premium payment for health insurance of an individual who is an employee in an amount of P2,500 per year may be deducted from gross income if his gross salary per year is not more than P250,000.
D. The Tax Code allows an individual taxpayer to pay in two equal installments, the first installment to be paid at the time the return is filed, and the second on or before July 15 of the same year, if his tax due exceeds P2,000.
E. An individual taxpayer can adopt either the calendar or fiscal period for purposes of filing his income tax return.
F. The capitalization rules may be resorted to by the BIR in order to compel corporate taxpayers to declare dividends to their stockholders regularly.
G. Informer’s reward is subject to a final withholding tax of 10%.
H. A non-resident alien who stays in the Philippines for less than 180 days during the calendar year shall be entitled to personal exemption not to exceed the amount allowed to citizens of the Philippines by the country of which he is subject or citizen.
Taxation Page 7 of 11
XI
Are the following transactions subject to VAT? If yes, what is the applicable rate for each transaction. State the relevant authority/ies for your answer.
A. Construction by XYZ Construction Co. of concrete barriers for the Asian Development Bank in Ortigas Center to prevent car bombs from ramming the ADB gates along ADB Avenue in Mandaluyong City. (3%)
B. Call Center operated by a domestic enterprise in Makati that handles exclusively the reservations of a hotel chain which are all located in North America. The services are paid for in US$ and duly accounted for with the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas. (3%)
C. Sale of orchids by a flower shop which raises its flowers in Tagaytay. (3%)
XII
Ferremaro, Inc., a manufacturer of handcrafted shoes, maintains its principal office in Cubao, Quezon City. It has branches/sales offices in Cebu and Davao. Its factory is located in Marikina City where most of its workers live. Its principal office in Quezon City is also a sales office.
Sales of finished products for calendar year 2009 in the amount of P10 million were made at the following locations:
i) ii) iii)
Cebu branch 25% Davao branch 15% Quezon City branch __60%
Total 100%
Taxation Page 8 of 11
Where should the applicable local taxes on the shoes be paid? Explain. (3%)
XIII
XYZ Shipping Corporation is a branch of an international shipping line with voyages between Manila and the West Coast of the U.S. The company’s vessels load and unload cargoes at the Port of Manila, albeit it does not have a branch or sales office in Manila. All the bills of lading and invoices are issued by the branch office in Makati which is also the company’s principal office.
The City of Manila enacted an ordinance levying a 2% tax on gross receipts of shipping lines using the Port of Manila.
Can the City Government of Manila legally impose said levy on the corporation? Explain. (3%)
XIV
A inherited a two-storey building in Makati from his father, a real estate broker in the ‘60s. A group of Tibetan monks approached A and offered to lease the building in order to use it as a venue for their Buddhist rituals and ceremonies. A accepted the rental of P1 million for the whole year.
The following year, the City Assessor issued an assessment against A for non-payment of real property taxes.
Is the assessor justified in assessing A’s deficiency real property taxes? Explain. (3%)
Taxation Page 9 of 11
XV
Don Sebastian, single but head of the family, Filipino, and resident of Pasig City, died intestate on November 15, 2009. He left the following properties and interests:
House and lot (family home) in Pasig
Vacation house and lot in Florida, USA
Agricultural land in Naic, Cavite which he inherited from his father
Car which is being used by his brother in Cavite
Proceeds of life insurance where he named his estate as irrevocable beneficiary
Household furnitures and appliances
Claims against a cousin who has assets of P10,000 and liabilities of P100,000
Shares of stock in ABC Corp, a domestic enterprise
P 800,000 1,500,000
2,000,000 500,000
1,000,000 1,000,000
100,000 100,000
The expenses and charges on the estate are as follows:
Funeral Expenses Legal fees for the settlement of the estate Medical expenses of last illness Claims against the estate
P 250,000 500,000 600,000 300,000
The compulsory heirs of Don Sebastian approach you and seek your assistance in the settlement of his estate for which they
Taxation Page 10 of 11
have agreed to the above-stated professional fees. Specifically, they request you to explain and discuss with them the following questions. You oblige:
A. What are the properties and interests that should be included in the computation of the gross estate of the decedent? Explain. (2.5%)
B. What is the net taxable estate of the decedent? Explain. (2.5%)
C. When is the due date for filing and payment of the applicable tax return and tax? Are these dates extendible? If so, under what conditions or requirements? (2.5%)
D. If X, one of the compulsory heirs, renounces his share in the inheritance in favor of the other co-heirs, is there any tax implication of X’s renunciation? What about the other co- heirs? (2.5%)
XVI
A is a travelling salesman working full time for Nu Skin Products. He receives a monthly salary plus 3% commission on his sales in a Southern province where he is based. He regularly uses his own car to maximize his visits even to far flung areas. One fine day a group of militants seized his car. He was notified the following day by the police that the marines and the militants had a bloody encounter and his car was completely destroyed after a grenade hit it.
A wants to file a claim for casualty loss. Explain the legal basis of your tax advice. (3%)
Taxation Page 11 of 11
XVII
In 2009, Caruso, a resident Filipino citizen, received dividend income from a U.S.-based corporation which owns a chain of Filipino restaurants in the West Coast, U.S.A. The dividend remitted to Caruso is subject to U.S. withholding tax with respect to a non-resident alien like Caruso.
A. What will be your advice to Caruso in order to lessen the impact of possible double taxation on the same income? (3%)
B. Would your answer in A. be the same if Caruso became a U.S. immigrant in 2008 and had become a non-resident Filipino citizen? Explain the difference in treatment for Philippine income tax purposes. (3%)
XVIII
ABC, a domestic corporation, entered into a software license agreement with XYZ, a non-resident foreign corporation based in the U.S. Under the agreement which the parties forged in the U.S., XYZ granted ABC the right to use a computer system program and to avail of technical know-how relative to such program. In consideration for such rights, ABC agreed to pay 5% of the revenues it receives from customers who will use and apply the program in the Philippines.
Discuss the tax implication of the transaction. (5%)
- NOTHING FOLLOWS -

Bar Exam 2010 - Taxation Questions

PART I I
True or False.
A. In civil cases involving the collection of internal revenue taxes, prescription is construed strictly against the government and liberally in favor of the taxpayer. (1%)
B. In criminal cases involving tax offenses punishable under the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC), prescription is construed strictly against the government. (1%)
C. In criminal cases where the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) has exclusive original jurisdiction, the right to file a separate civil action for the recovery of taxes may be reserved. (1%)
D. Proceedings before the CTA in the exercise of its exclusive original jurisdiction are in the nature of trial de novo. (1%)
E. Judgments, resolutions or orders of the Regional Trial Court in the exercise of its original jurisdiction involving criminal offenses arising from violations of the NIRC are appealable to the CTA, which shall hear the cases en banc. (1%)
II A. What is the “all events test”? Explain briefly. (2%)
B. What is the “immediacy test”? Explain briefly. (2%) C. What is the “rational basis” test? Explain briefly. (2%)
D. What is the effect of the execution by a taxpayer of a “waiver of the statute of limitations” on his defense of prescription? (2%)
Taxation Page 3 of 11
E. What is the basis for the computation of business tax on contractors under the Local Government Code? (2%)
F. How are retiring businesses taxed under the Local Government Code? (2%)
III
Mirador, Inc., a domestic corporation, filed its Annual Income Tax Return for its taxable year 2008 on April 15, 2009. In the Return, it reflected an income tax overpayment of P1,000,000.00 and indicated its choice to carry-over the overpayment as an automatic tax credit against its income tax liabilities in subsequent years.
On April 15, 2010, it filed its Annual Income Tax Return for its taxable year 2009 reflecting a taxable loss and an income tax overpayment for the current year 2009 in the amount of P500,000.00 and its income tax overpayment for the prior year 2008 of P1,000,000.00.
In its 2009 Return, the corporation indicated its option to claim for refund the total income tax overpayment of P1,500,000.00
Choose which of the following statements is correct.
A. Mirador, Inc. may claim as refund the total income tax overpayment of P1,500,000.00 reflected in its income tax return for its taxable year 2009;
B. It may claim as refund the amount of P500,000.00 representing its income tax overpayment for its taxable year 2009; or
C. No amount may be claimed as refund. Explain the basis of your answer. (5%)
Taxation Page 4 of 11
IV
On March 10, 2010, Continental, Inc. received a preliminary assessment notice (PAN) dated March 1, 2010 issued by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR) for deficiency income tax for its taxable year 2008. It failed to protest the PAN. The CIR thereupon issued a final assessment notice (FAN) with letter of demand on April 30, 2010. The FAN was received by the corporation on May 10, 2010, following which or on May 25, 2010, it filed its protest against it.
The CIR denied the protest on the ground that the assessment had already become final and executory, the corporation having failed to protest the PAN.
Is the CIR correct? Explain. (5%)
V
Does the Court of Appeals have the power to review compromise agreements forged by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and a taxpayer? Explain. (5%)
VI
Based on the Affidavit of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR), an Information for failure to file income tax return under Section 255 of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) was filed by the Department of Justice (DOJ) with the Manila Regional Trial Court (RTC) against XX, a Manila resident.
XX moved to quash the Information on the ground that the RTC has no jurisdiction in view of the absence of a formal deficiency tax assessment issued by the CIR.
Is a prior assessment necessary before an Information for violation of Section 255 of the NIRC could be filed in court? Explain. (4%)
Taxation Page 5 of 11
VII
What are the conditions that must be complied with before the Court of Tax Appeals may suspend the collection of national internal revenue taxes? (3%)
VIII
What is the rule on appeal from decisions of the Collector of Customs in protest and seizure cases? When is the decision of the Collector of Customs appealable to the Court of Tax Appeals? Explain. (5%)
IX
On May 15, 2009, La Manga Trading Corporation received a deficiency business tax assessment of P1,500,000.00 from the Pasay City Treasurer. On June 30, 2009, the corporation contested the assessment by filing a written protest with the City Treasurer.
On October 10, 2009, the corporation received a collection letter from the City Treasurer, drawing it to file on October 25, 2009 an appeal against the assessment before the Pasay Regional Trial Court (RTC).
A. Was the protest of the corporation filed on time? Explain. (3%)
B. Was the appeal with the Pasay RTC filed on time? Explain. (3%)
- END OF PART I-
Taxation Page 6 of 11
PART II X
True or False. (1% each) A. Gains realized by the investor upon redemption of shares of
stock in a mutual fund company are exempt from income tax.
B. A corporation can claim the optional standard deduction equivalent to 40% of its gross sales or receipts, as the case may be.
C. Premium payment for health insurance of an individual who is an employee in an amount of P2,500 per year may be deducted from gross income if his gross salary per year is not more than P250,000.
D. The Tax Code allows an individual taxpayer to pay in two equal installments, the first installment to be paid at the time the return is filed, and the second on or before July 15 of the same year, if his tax due exceeds P2,000.
E. An individual taxpayer can adopt either the calendar or fiscal period for purposes of filing his income tax return.
F. The capitalization rules may be resorted to by the BIR in order to compel corporate taxpayers to declare dividends to their stockholders regularly.
G. Informer’s reward is subject to a final withholding tax of 10%.
H. A non-resident alien who stays in the Philippines for less than 180 days during the calendar year shall be entitled to personal exemption not to exceed the amount allowed to citizens of the Philippines by the country of which he is subject or citizen.
Taxation Page 7 of 11
XI
Are the following transactions subject to VAT? If yes, what is the applicable rate for each transaction. State the relevant authority/ies for your answer.
A. Construction by XYZ Construction Co. of concrete barriers for the Asian Development Bank in Ortigas Center to prevent car bombs from ramming the ADB gates along ADB Avenue in Mandaluyong City. (3%)
B. Call Center operated by a domestic enterprise in Makati that handles exclusively the reservations of a hotel chain which are all located in North America. The services are paid for in US$ and duly accounted for with the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas. (3%)
C. Sale of orchids by a flower shop which raises its flowers in Tagaytay. (3%)
XII
Ferremaro, Inc., a manufacturer of handcrafted shoes, maintains its principal office in Cubao, Quezon City. It has branches/sales offices in Cebu and Davao. Its factory is located in Marikina City where most of its workers live. Its principal office in Quezon City is also a sales office.
Sales of finished products for calendar year 2009 in the amount of P10 million were made at the following locations:
i) ii) iii)
Cebu branch 25% Davao branch 15% Quezon City branch __60%
Total 100%
Taxation Page 8 of 11
Where should the applicable local taxes on the shoes be paid? Explain. (3%)
XIII
XYZ Shipping Corporation is a branch of an international shipping line with voyages between Manila and the West Coast of the U.S. The company’s vessels load and unload cargoes at the Port of Manila, albeit it does not have a branch or sales office in Manila. All the bills of lading and invoices are issued by the branch office in Makati which is also the company’s principal office.
The City of Manila enacted an ordinance levying a 2% tax on gross receipts of shipping lines using the Port of Manila.
Can the City Government of Manila legally impose said levy on the corporation? Explain. (3%)
XIV
A inherited a two-storey building in Makati from his father, a real estate broker in the ‘60s. A group of Tibetan monks approached A and offered to lease the building in order to use it as a venue for their Buddhist rituals and ceremonies. A accepted the rental of P1 million for the whole year.
The following year, the City Assessor issued an assessment against A for non-payment of real property taxes.
Is the assessor justified in assessing A’s deficiency real property taxes? Explain. (3%)
Taxation Page 9 of 11
XV
Don Sebastian, single but head of the family, Filipino, and resident of Pasig City, died intestate on November 15, 2009. He left the following properties and interests:
House and lot (family home) in Pasig
Vacation house and lot in Florida, USA
Agricultural land in Naic, Cavite which he inherited from his father
Car which is being used by his brother in Cavite
Proceeds of life insurance where he named his estate as irrevocable beneficiary
Household furnitures and appliances
Claims against a cousin who has assets of P10,000 and liabilities of P100,000
Shares of stock in ABC Corp, a domestic enterprise
P 800,000 1,500,000
2,000,000 500,000
1,000,000 1,000,000
100,000 100,000
The expenses and charges on the estate are as follows:
Funeral Expenses Legal fees for the settlement of the estate Medical expenses of last illness Claims against the estate
P 250,000 500,000 600,000 300,000
The compulsory heirs of Don Sebastian approach you and seek your assistance in the settlement of his estate for which they
Taxation Page 10 of 11
have agreed to the above-stated professional fees. Specifically, they request you to explain and discuss with them the following questions. You oblige:
A. What are the properties and interests that should be included in the computation of the gross estate of the decedent? Explain. (2.5%)
B. What is the net taxable estate of the decedent? Explain. (2.5%)
C. When is the due date for filing and payment of the applicable tax return and tax? Are these dates extendible? If so, under what conditions or requirements? (2.5%)
D. If X, one of the compulsory heirs, renounces his share in the inheritance in favor of the other co-heirs, is there any tax implication of X’s renunciation? What about the other co- heirs? (2.5%)
XVI
A is a travelling salesman working full time for Nu Skin Products. He receives a monthly salary plus 3% commission on his sales in a Southern province where he is based. He regularly uses his own car to maximize his visits even to far flung areas. One fine day a group of militants seized his car. He was notified the following day by the police that the marines and the militants had a bloody encounter and his car was completely destroyed after a grenade hit it.
A wants to file a claim for casualty loss. Explain the legal basis of your tax advice. (3%)
Taxation Page 11 of 11
XVII
In 2009, Caruso, a resident Filipino citizen, received dividend income from a U.S.-based corporation which owns a chain of Filipino restaurants in the West Coast, U.S.A. The dividend remitted to Caruso is subject to U.S. withholding tax with respect to a non-resident alien like Caruso.
A. What will be your advice to Caruso in order to lessen the impact of possible double taxation on the same income? (3%)
B. Would your answer in A. be the same if Caruso became a U.S. immigrant in 2008 and had become a non-resident Filipino citizen? Explain the difference in treatment for Philippine income tax purposes. (3%)
XVIII
ABC, a domestic corporation, entered into a software license agreement with XYZ, a non-resident foreign corporation based in the U.S. Under the agreement which the parties forged in the U.S., XYZ granted ABC the right to use a computer system program and to avail of technical know-how relative to such program. In consideration for such rights, ABC agreed to pay 5% of the revenues it receives from customers who will use and apply the program in the Philippines.
Discuss the tax implication of the transaction. (5%)
- NOTHING FOLLOWS -

Case Digest - Taxation

ALTERNATIVE CENTER FOR ORGANIZATION REFORMS VS ZAMORA
GRN 144256 June 8, 2005
Carpio-Morales, J.:

FACTS:
In the year 2000, the GAA appropriated PhP 111,778,000,000.00 of IRA as programmed fund. It appropriated a separate amount of P10B of IRA under the classification of unprogrammed fund, the latter amount to be released only upon th occurrence of the conditions stated in the GAA.

ISSUE:
Whether or not the questioned provision violate the constitutional injunction that the just share of local governments in the national taxes of the IRA shall be automatically released.

RULING:
Article X Section 6 of the Constitution provides: “LGUs shall have a just share, as determined by law, in the national taxes which shall be automatically released to them.” While automatice release implies that the just share should be released to them as a matter of course, withholding its release pending an event contravened the constitutional mandate.

===========================

AMERICAN BIBLE SOCIETY VS MANILA
GRN 9637 April 30, 1957
Felix, J.:

FACTS:
Plaintiff-appellant is a foreign, non-stock, non-profit, religious, missionary corporation and in the course of its ministry, it has been selling bible and or gospel portions throughout the country and translating the same into several Philippine dialects. The City of Manila considered appellant as conducting the business of general merchandize and required it to secure the necessary permit and license fees.

ISSUE:
Whether or not appellant if engaged in business as a religious corporation and thus be made to pay fees or taxes.

RULING:
It may be true that the price of bibles and pamphlets was a bit higher than the actual cost of the same, but this could not mean that appellant is engaged in business for profit. For this reason, we believe that the ordinance requiring them to pay fees or taxes would impair its free exercise of its religious freedom thru distribution of pamphlets.

==================================
CIR VS. BRITISH OVERSEAS AIRWAYS
GRN L-65773-74 April 30, 1987
En Banc, Melecio-Herrera, J.:

FACTS:
British Overseas Airways is a 100% British Government-owned corporation engaged in international airline business and is a member of the Interline Air Transport Association and thus it operates air transportation service and sells transportation tickets over the routes of the other airline members. From 1959 to 1972, BOAC had no landing rights for traffic purposes in the Philippines but maintained a general sales agent in the country. Warner Barnes was responsible for selling BOAC tickets covering passengers of and cargos. The CIR assessed deficiency income taxes against BOAC.

ISSUE:
Whether or not the revenue derived by BOAC from ticket sales in the Philippines for its transportation constitute income from Philippine sources and accordingly taxable.

RULING:
The source of an income is the property, activity or service that produced the income. For the source of income to be considered as coming from the Philippines, it is sufficient that the income is derived from activity within the Philippines. Herein, the sale of tickets is the activity that produced the income. The tickets exchanged hands here and payment for fares were also made here in the Philippine currency. The situs or the source of the payment is the Philippines. The flow of wealth proceeded from, and occurred within, Philippine territory, enjoying the protection accorded by Philippine government. In consideration of such protection, the flow of wealth should share the burden of supporting the government. PD 68, in relation to PD1355, ensures that international airlines are taxed on their income from Philippine sources. The 2.5% tax on gross billings is an income tax. If it had been intended as an excise tax, it would have been placed under Title V of the Tax Code covering taxes on business.

Case Digest - Taxation

CITY ASSESSOR OF CEBU VS. ASSOCIATION OF BENEVOLA DE CEBU
G.R 152904 June 28, 2007
Velasco, Jr. J.:
FACTS:
Benevola de Cebu is a non-stock non-profit organization which in 1990, a medical arts building was constructed and in 1998 was issued with a certification classifying the building as commercial. City assessor of Cebu assessed the building with a market value of Php 28,060,520 and on assessed value of Php 9,821,180 at the assessment level of 35% and not 10% which is currently imposed on private respondent herein. Petitioner claimed that the building is used as commercial clinic/spaces for renting out to physicians and thus classified as commercial. Benevola de Cebu contended that the building is used actually, directly and exclusively part of hospital and should have an assessment level of 10%

ISSUE:
Whether or not the new building is liable to pay the 35% assessment level?
RULING:
We hold that the new building is an integral part of the hospital and should not be assessed as commercial. Being a tertiary hospital, it is mandated to fully departmentalized and be equipped with the service capabilities needed to support certified medical specialist and other licensed physicians. The fact that they are holding office is a separate building does not take away the essence and nature of their services vis-a-vis the overall operation of the hospital and to its patients.
Under the Local Government Code, Sec. 26: All lands, buildings and other improvements thereon actually, directly and exclusively used for hospitals, cultural or scientific purposes and those owned and used by local water districts… shall be classified as special.

=======================================
Associaiton of Customs Brokers vs Manila
GRN L-4376 May 22, 1953
En Banc
FACTS:
The Municipal Board of Manila passed ordinance No. 3379 which imposes a property tax that is within the power of the City under its revised charter. The ordinance was passed by the Municipal Board under the authority conferred by section 18 of RA 409

ISSUE:
Whether or not the ordinance infringes on the uniformity of taxes as ordained by the Constitution.
RULING:
The Ordinance exacts the tax upon all motor vehicles operating within Manila and does not distinguish between a motor vehicle registered in the City and one registered in another place nor does it distinguish private of vehicle for hire. The distinction is important if we note that the ordinance intends to burden with the tax only those registered in Manila. There is no pretense that the Ordinance equally applies to vehicles who come to Manila for a temporary purpose.

Case Digest - Taxation

BENGZON VS. DRILON
G.R. 103524 April 15, 1992 208 SCRA 133
Gutierrez, J.:

FACTS:
Petitioners are retired justices of the Supreme Court and Court of Appeals who are currently receiving pensions under RA 910 as amended by RA 1797. President Marcos issued a decree repealing section 3-A of RA 1797 which authorized the adjustment of the pension of retired justices and officers and enlisted members of the AFP. PD 1638 was eventually issued by Marcos which provided for the automatic readjustment of the pension of officers and enlisted men was restored, while that of the retired justices was not. RA 1797 was restored through HB 16297 in 1990. When her advisers gave the wrong information that the questioned provisions in 1992 GAA were an attempt to overcome her earlier veto in 1990, President Aquino issued the veto now challenged in this petition.
It turns out that PD 644 which repealed RA 1797 never became a valid law absent its publication, thus there was no law. It follows that RA 1797 was still in effect and HB 16297 was superfluous because it tried to restore benefits which were never taken away validly. The veto of HB 16297 did not also produce any effect.
ISSUE:
Whether or not the veto of the President of certain provisions in the GAA of FY 1992 relating to the payment of the adjusted pensions of retired Justices is constitutional or valid.
RULING:
The veto of these specific provisions in the GAA is tantamount to dictating to the Judiciary ot its funds should be utilized, which is clearly repugnant to fiscal autonomy. Pursuant to constitutional mandate, the Judiciary must enjoy freedom in the disposition of the funds allocated to it in the appropriations law.
Any argument which seeks to remove special privileges given by law to former Justices on the ground that there should be no grant of distinct privileges or “preferential treatment” to retired Justices ignores these provisions of the Constitution and in effect asks that these Constitutional provisions on special protections for the Judiciary be repealed.
The petition is granted and the questioned veto is illegal and the provisions of 1992 GAA are declared valid and subsisting.

REYES VS. ALMANZOR
GR 43839-46 April 26, 1991 196 SCRA 322
Paras, J.:
FACTS:
Petitioner are owners of parcels of land leased to tenants. RA 6359 was enacted prohibiting for one year an increase in monthly rentals of dwelling units and said Act also disallowed ejectment of lessees upon the expiration of the usual period of lease. City assessor of Manila assessed the value of petitioner’s property based on the schedule of market values duly reviewed by the Secretary of Finance. The revision entailed an increase to the tax rates and petitioners averred that the reassessment imposed upon them greatly exceeded the annual income derived from their properties.
ISSUE:
Whether or not income approach is the method to be used in the tax assessment and not the comparable sales approach.
RULING:
By no stretch of the imagination can the market value of properties covered by PD 20 be equated with the market value of properties not so covered. In the case at bar, not even factors determinant of the assessed value of subject properties under the comparable sales approach were presented by respondent namely:
1. That the sale must represent a bonafide arm’s length transaction between a willing seller and a willing buyer
2. The property must be comparable property.
As a general rule, there were no takers so that there can be no reasonable basis for the conclusion that these properties are comparable.
Taxes are lifeblood of government, however, such collection should be made in accordance with the law and therefore necessary to reconcile conflicting interests of the authorities so that the real purpose of taxation, promotion of the welfare of common good can be achieved.

LLADOC V CIR & CTA
GR 19201 June 16, 1965 14 SCRA 293
Paredes, J.:

FACTS:
MB Estate of Bacolod City donated Php 10,000 in cash to Fr. Ruiz, then the Parish Priest of Victorias, who was the predecessor of petitioner. MB Estate filed their donor’s gift tax but petitioner is on protest regarding donee’s tax claiming that assessment of gift tax against the Catholic Church is against the law; that when the donation was made. He was not yet the parish priest.
ISSUE:
Whether or not petitioner should be liable for assessed donee’s gift tax dontated.

RULING:
A gift tax is not a property tax, but an excise tax imposed on the transfer of property by way of gift inter vivos, the imposition of which on property used exclusively for religious purposes, does not constitute an impairment of Constitution… “exempt from taxation” as employed in the Constitution should not be interpreted to mean exemption from all kinds of taxes. And there being no clear, positive or express grant of such privilege by law, in favor of petitioner, the exemption herein must be denied.


LUNG CENTER VS. QUEZON CITY
GR 144104 June29, 2004
En Banc, Callejo J:
Facts:
The lung center is a charitable institution within the context of 1973 and 1987 constitutions. The elements considered in determining a charitable institution are: the statue creating the enterprise; its corporate purposes; constitution and by-laws, methods of administration, nature of actual work performed, character of the services rendered, indefiniteness of the beneficiaries, and the use occupation of properties. As a gen. principle, a charitable institution doe not lose its character as such and its exemption form taxes simply because it derives income from paying patients, or receives subsidies from government; and no money insures to the private benefit of the persons managing or operating the institution.
Issue:
Whether or not the real properties of the lung center are exempt from real property taxes.
Ruling.
Partly No. Those portions of its real property that are leased to private entities are not exempt from actually, direct and exclusively used for charitable purpose. Under PD 1823, the lung center does not enjoy any property tax exemption privileges for its real properties as well as the building constructed thereon.
The property tax exemption under Sec. 28(3), Art. Vi of the property taxes only. This provision was implanted by Sec.243 (b) of RA 7160.which provides that in order to be entitled to the exemption, the lung center must be able to prove that: it is a charitable institution and; its real properties are actually, directly and exclusively used for charitable purpose. Accordingly, the portions occupied by the hospital used for its patients are exempt from real property taxes while those leased to private entities are not exempt from such taxes.

Case Digest - Taxation

LUTZ VS. ARANETA

GR L-7859 December 22, 1955
Reyes, J.:
FACTS:
Walter Lutz, Judicial Administrator of the intestate estate of Ledesma, sought to recover the sum of Php14, 666.40 paid by the estate as taxes, alleging that such tax is unconstitutional as it levied for the aid and support of the sugar industry exclusively which is in his opinion not a public purpose.
ISSUE:
Whether or not tax is valid in supporting the sugar industry?
RULING:
The court ruled that the tax is valid as it served public purpose. The tax provided for in CA 567 is primarily an exercise of police power since sugar is a great source of income for the country and employs thousands of laborers. Hence, it was competent for the legislature to find that the general welfare demanded that the sugar industry should be stabilized in turn; and in the wide field of its police power, the lawmaking body could provide that the distribution of benefits therefrom be readjusted among its components to enable it to resist the added strain of the increase in taxes that it had to sustain.

COMMISSIONER OF IR VS CENTRAL LUZON DRUG CORP
GR 148512 June 26, 2006
Azcuna, J.:
FACTS:
This is a petition for review under Rule 45 of Rules of Court seeking the nullification of CA decision granting respondent’s claim for tax equal to the amount of the 20% that it extended to senior citizens on the latter’s purchases pursuant to Senior Citizens Act. Respondent deducted the total amount of Php219,778 from its gross income for the taxable year 1995 whereby respondent did not pay tax for that year reporting a net loss of Php20,963 in its corporate income tax. In 1996, claiming that the Php219,778 should be applied as a tax credit, respondent claimed for refund in the amount of Php150, 193.
ISSUE:
Whether or not the 20% discount granted by the respondent to qualified senior citizens may be claimed as tax credit or as deduction from gross sales?
RULING:
“Tax credit” is explicitly provided for in Sec4 of RA 7432. The discount given to Senior citizens is a tax credit, not a deduction from the gross sales of the establishment concerned. The tax credit that is contemplated under this Act is a form of just compensation, not a remedy for taxes that were erroneously or illegally assessed and collected. In the same vein, prior payment of any tax liability is a pre-condition before a taxable entity can benefit from tax credit. The credit may be availed of upon payment, if any. Where there is no tax liability or where a private establishment reports a net loss for the period, the tax credit can be availed of and carried over to the next taxable year.

APOSTOLIC PREFECT VS CITY TREASURER OF BAGUIO CITY
GR 4752 April 18, 1941
Imperial, J.:
FACTS:
The Apostolic Prefect is a corporation , of religious character, organized under the Philippine laws, and with residence in Baguio. The City imposed a special assessment against properties within its territorial jurisdiction, including those of the Apostolic Prefect, which benefits from its drainage and sewerage system. The Apostolic Prefect contends that its properties should be free of tax being of religious in character.
ISSUE:
Whether or not Apostolic Prefect, as a religious entity is exempt from the payment of the special assessment.
RULING:
A special assessment is not a tax; and neither the decree nor the Constitution exempt petitioner from payment of said special assessment. Although it its broad meaning, tax includes both general taxes and special assessment, yet there is a recognized distinction: Assessment is confined to local impositions upon property for the payment of the cost of public improvements in its immediate vicinity and levied with special benefits to the property assessed. Petitioner likewise, has proven that the property in question is used exclusively for religious purposes; but that it appears the same is being used to other non-religious purposes. Thus, petitioner is required to pay the special assessment.

PAL VS EDU
HR L-41383 August 15, 1988
Gutierrez, J.:
FACTS:
PAL is engaged in air transportation business under a legislative franchise wherein it is exempt from tax payment. PAL has not been paying motor vehicle registration since 1956. The Land Registration Commissioner required all tax exempt entities including PAL to pay motor vehicle registration fees.
ISSUE:
Whether or not registration fees as to motor vehicles are taxes to which PAL is exempted.
RULING:
Taxes are for revenue whereas fees are exactions for purposes of regulation and inspection, and are for that reason limited in amount to what is necessary to cover the cost of the services rendered in that connection. It is the object of the charge, and not the name, that determines whether a charge is a tax or a fee. The money collected under Motor Vehicle Law is not intended for the expenditures of the MV Office but accrues to the funds for the construction and maintenance of public roads, streets and bridges.
As fees are not collected for regulatory purposes as an incident to the enforcement of regulations governing the operation of motor vehicles on public highways but to provide revenue with which the Government is to construct and maintain public highways for everyone’s use, they are veritable taxes, not merely fees. PAL is thus exempt from paying such fees, except for the period between June 27, 1968 to April 9, 1979 where its tax exemption in the franchise was repealed.

CALTEX PHILIPPINES VS CA
G.R. 925585 MAY 8, 1992
Davide, J.:
FACTS:
In 1989, COA sent a letter to Caltex directing it to remit to OPSF its collection of the additional tax on petroleum authorized under PD 1956 and pending such remittance, all of its claims from the OPSF shall be held in abeyance. Petitioner requested COA for the early release of its reimbursement certificates from the OPSF covering claims with the Office of Energy Affairs. COA denied the same.
ISSUE:
Whether of not petitioner can avail of the right to offset any amount that it may be required under the law to remit to the OPSF against any amount that it may receive by way of reimbursement.
RULING:
It is a settled rule that a taxpayer may not offset taxes due from the claims that he may have against the government. Taxes cannot be the subject of compensation because the government and taxpayer are not mutually debtors and creditors of each other and a claim for taxes is not such a debt, demand, contract or judgment as is allowed to be set-off.
The oil companies merely acted as agents for the government in the latter’s collection since taxes are passed unto the end-users, the consuming public.

DOMINGO VS GARLITOS
G.R. NO. 18993 June 29, 1963
Labrador, J.:
FACTS:
In Domingo vs. Moscoso, the Supreme Court declared as final and executor the order of the lower court for the payment of estate and inheritance taxes, charges and penalties amounting to Php 40,058.55 by the estate of the of the late Walter Price. The petitioner for execution filed by the fiscal was denied by the lower court. The court held that the execution is unjustified as the Government is indebted to the estate for Php262,200 and ordered the amount of inheritance taxes can be deducted from the Government’s indebtedness to the estate.
ISSUE:
Whether of not a tax and a debt may be compensated.
RULING:
The court having jurisdiction of the Estate had found that the claim of the Estate against the government has been recognized and the amount has already been appropriated by a corresponding law. Both the claim of the Government for inheritance taxes and the claim of the intestate for services rendered have already become overdue and demandable is well as fully liquidated. Compensation takes place by operation of law and both debts are extinguished to the concurrent amount. Therefore the petitioner has no clear right to execute the judgment for taxes against the estate of the deceased Walter Price.

GARCIA VS. EXECUTIVE SECRETARY
211 SCRA 219 July 3, 1992
Feliciano, J.:

FACTS:
The President issued an EO which imposed, across the board, including crude oil and other oil products, additional duty ad valorem. The Tariff Commission held public hearings on said EO and submitted a report to the President for consideration and appropriate action. The President, on the other hand issued an EO which levied a special duty of P0.95 per liter of imported crude oil and P1.00 per liter of imported oil products.
ISSUE:
Whether of not the President may issue an EO which is tantamount to enacting a bill in the nature of revenue-generating measures.
RULING:
The Court said that although the enactment of appropriation, revenue and tariff bills is within the province of the Legislative, it does not follow that EO in question, assuming they may be characterized as revenue measure are prohibited to the President, that they must be enacted instead by Congress. Section 28 of Article VI of the 1987 Constitution provides:
“The Congress may, by law authorize the President to fix… tariff rates and other duties or imposts…”
The relevant Congressional statute is the Tariff and Customs Code of the Philippines and Sections 104 and 401, the pertinent provisions thereof.

Powered by Blogger.